Below is my word doc draft for feedback
Thanks
Step 1
Chapter 4
Well it’s Thursday night (23-4-15) I’m in camp at Nebo for
work and while I begin this I am also watching Australia: The story of us. If
you are anything like me then you also put down your work to reflect on
Australia’s great moments and people, tonight was the doctor who invented the
cochlear implant and the Americas cup win, and Cathy Freeman winning at the Sydney
Olympics great moments that gave me goosebumps and a reminds me of my pride in
Australia. Enough of the patriotic stuff and onto chapter 4 I was interested
when I read about adding value and looking at free cash flow and economic
profit. Free cash flow is simply operating income minus investment in net
operating assets. Economic profit on the other hand is the return from
operating assets above the capital costs.
The next piece of information the was interesting to read
was restating the financial statements, at first this seemed reasonably easy to
do, how hard could it be to split a firms financial activities from its
operating activities I read and understood the reasons for it. When putting
this into practice for the first time though it immediately became strange and
back to the reading I went. The reason for restating is to look closely at both
the operating side of business and the financial side of business separately
from each other, this is so we can look at areas that have the most potential
to add value to firms and look at more specific relationships in the firm.
Restating in it’s theory is simple, look at the statements and separate those
activities that belong to operations and those that belong to financial, I’m
sure with practice I will be able to achieve restating times of 5 minutes like
Martin but for now I have to accept it will take 5 minutes per item to restate.
I found the relationship between profitability and
efficiency to be interesting I have seen like many others the concept of
profitability in business, it is used constantly and spoken about a lot however
I have not yet come across efficiency or at least not realised it. I see how
this is important if you had to spend $100 to generate $1 of turnover then you
would be investing heavily to generate little turnover. However these numbers
work best when looked at together, Martin’s example showed profitability of
66.9% with ATO 0.35 cents per dollar of NOA to create the RNOA of 23.2%. It
would seem that as your profit margin drops then you would want the efficiency
to increase so that the RNOA remains strong, for instance if Martin’s PM was
let’s say 10% and the ATO remains 0.35 cents then the RNOA would be 3.5%. This
would cause a dramatic effect on the economic profit and would cause a loss. To
keep making a profit that they are with a PM of 10% they would have to increase
the ATO to 2.3 dollars.
Step 2
Well restating Emeco Holding statements was at the beginning
very frustrating, I thought I had read the text well enough and thought it to
be not too difficult but one I started I went to Jelly. I left the computer for
the day and returned later to look over it again.
I found when I sat and looked through each item slowly and
thought about it logically in conjunction with the reports notes then I found
the exercise much easier. I had to refer to the text and example assignments to
see the layout of restated financials, once I got a roll on then I got through
the job quiet quickly.
I did make some simple errors when I did basic checks like
NFO + Equity didn’t match NOA but after some quick checks I found the mistake
was in the formula to calculate my cash assets for operating and financial.
I also got a little stuck with the income statement with the
tax benefit and were to add and subtract these from, the main culprit was when
Emeco had a tax expense of a positive. This tripped me up as to whether or not
I needed to add or subtract the benefit.
I also consulted on facebook with many students to find if
others were having troubles with similar things. I asked several questions and
had great feedback from other as well as commenting on some posts from Norman
Tanen, Claire Pepper and Katrina Saunders.
Step 3
My company Emeco being an Earth works equipment company sell
both products (earthmoving equipment) and services (maintenance labour) The
three products and services I have identified are below.
1 – Maintenance Labour – $80 p/h. I have chosen this rate
based on what I know of the industry. Heavy earthmoving maintenance personal
are charged out anywhere between $75 - $85 p/h. Of this $80 around $40 would be
the persons wage, other variable costs would be superannuation, work cover, LSL,
site allowances (or annual leave depending on fulltime or casual status) and
payroll tax, these are all tied to the wage as a percentage, Therefor I would
calculate the contribution margin to be CM = Sales – Variable costs. So CM = $80 - $65
therefore CM = $15. This is based on a 12 hour work day
2 – Second hand CAT740 – AT104 – $185 000 This item was
found on Emeco stock list for their second hand equipment. The variable costs
on this item would be labour to bring to selling point, parts, transport etc.
The contribution margin would be something like CM = Sales – variable costs so
CM = $185 000 – $135 000 so CM =
$50 000
3 - CAT 385C EX149 – $350 000 – Again this came from the
Emeco stock list, it would have the same variable items as above but the price
is different so would show a different CM for example CM = Sales – Variable
costs, CM = $350 000 – $280 000 so CM = $70 000.
The contribution margin for each product and service varies
as each product and service is different, with labour the volume would be
higher so the CM can be lower as opposed to the machinery were the turnover may
be low and require a higher CM. The other question to look at is why not just
sell the machines because of a better CM, this would work against Emeco. If
they don’t offer a maintenance service and the machinery then potential
customers may not buy their products. Would you buy a car from Toyota if they
didn’t offer any servicing?